So Much for "Disciplining" Bybee Without Impeaching or Prosecuting Him, But Bush and Cheney Not Helped

Jay Bybee is a member of the D.C. bar and could be complained about there and disbarred, since apparently enforcing the laws he violated or impeaching him would just be too much trouble. Except that, as Gordon Clark pointed out to me, the Washington Post just printed a letter from the “senior legal ethics counsel for the District of Columbia Bar” essentially objecting the existence of ethics:

Regarding the May 7 news story “Experts Say Authors of Memos May Avoid Professional Sanctions”:

The story discussed the difficulties inherent in efforts to impose professional sanctions on Bush administration lawyers who drafted memoranda supporting the harsh interrogation of terrorist suspects.

If a client instructs his lawyer, “I want to perform a certain act; find me a legal way to do it,” the lawyer’s professional duty is to find a good-faith basis in the law to meet the client’s needs while carefully advising the client of the risks of pursuing such a course of action. Such a lawyer not only acts well within the Rules of Professional Conduct, but he also serves his client well.

Waterboarding is a perfect example. A lawyer may personally believe that such a practice constitutes torture, but there is, at the very least, a good-faith argument to be made that it is not — as evidenced by the fact that even now respected authorities argue that this is not torture. Thus, even if the ultimate arbiter decides that waterboarding is torture, that does not mean that lawyers who advised to the contrary should be professionally disciplined.

SAUL JAY SINGER

Washington

The writer is senior legal ethics counsel for the District of Columbia Bar.

The really good news here is that for people who think like this and want to protect mafia lawyers like Bybee, Bush and Cheney are not provided any cover by the “good faith” memos. The memos are merely opinions, not laws. A court can admit the obvious, that waterboarding is torture, and put Bush and Cheney in prison for it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *